Acting Out of Character in the Immortal Profession: Toward a Free Trait Agreement

By Brian R. Little  |  From the April-May 2010 Issue of Academic Matters

-Sometimes, the academic life demands that faculty deny their fundamental personality traits. But if collegial respect includes allowing colleagues the latitude to nurture their true characters, academics can survive and thrive amidst the challenges of academic life.

It often comes down to personality. Despite the candidate’s obvious brilliance, tenure is denied. The comment “insufferably arrogant,” uttered almost sotto voce just before the vote, helps tip the scales.  Across campus a dedicated but painfully shy associate professor is reading the term’s teaching evaluations and, once again, is simply devastated. And over at the faculty club, a newly minted Professor Emeritus bounces into the retirement party to find only three attendees at the event, trying in vain to create the illusion of a throng. Later, at the bar, the reluctant pseudo-celebrants agree on one thing — this wouldn’t have happened to any of their other colleagues. Personality matters.

Human personality plays a striking and subtle role in shaping the course of our lives in the immortal profession. Arrogance, shyness, bounciness, and hundreds of other traits of personality influence how others see us and how we see ourselves. They have important consequences for the shape of our lives. What do we know about these influences? How are they striking? What’s so subtle?

Light can be shone on these questions by contemporary research in the field of personality science. Personality science studies a broad spectrum of influences upon human conduct, ranging from neurons to narratives. One of its most important sub-fields explores relatively fixed traits of human personality. William James, the philosopher/psychologist, proposed that such traits, by the age of thirty, are “set like plaster.” Was James right? Are our professorial styles attributable to traits that are essentially immutable? Was that arrogance apparent early on? Can that shyness be a life sentence? Is that bounciness irrepressible? Trait psychologists would argue that the answer is “yes” to each of these questions, and I partially agree. However, I will argue that the notion of fixed traits being set like plaster goes too far. I propose that human beings are essentially half-plastered. Let’s explore further.

Personality Traits: The Big Five

Many personality researchers have concluded that the hundreds of different trait dimensions can be reduced to five major factors that consistently emerge in data collected across different cultures and language groups. The so-called big five dimensions are: open to experience (vs. closed-minded), coscientious (vs. careless), extraverted (vs. introverted), agreeable (vs. disagreeable) and neurotic (vs. stable). These dimensions are statistically independent of each other, so that one’s status on any big five dimension is independent of that on any other. An extraverted professor, for example, may be open or closed, stable or neurotic, sweet or surly.

Each of the big five dimensions can be linked to important aspects of human flourishing, such as marital stability, creative achievement, and health. For example, conscientiousness is associated with greater success, particularly in conventional areas of achievement and is also linked to better physical health. However, in at least one occupation, that of jazz musicians, greater conscientiousness is associated with less success as rated by other musicians. Why do conscientious jazz musicians strike a discordant note with fellow musicians? I suspect that the focus and orderliness associated with conscientiousness interferes with the capacity to detect subtle intimations of key transformations or pitch changes. Open individuals excel in creative domains, while conscientious ones do better in more conventional areas. Agreeable people are particularly successful at group activities, and disagreeable ones are particularly at risk for cardiovascular disorders.

Most professionals are expected to be open, conscientious, moderately extraverted, initially agreeable, and stable rather than neurotic.  I believe that this profile holds for academics as well, although we have greater latitude of acceptance of variations.  Extreme deviations from these traits, however, are often seen as strange—including deviations on the more “positive” side. A colleague who is closed, careless, and cranky is unlikely to be seen as a valued colleague, except perhaps by those with similar personalities. But being overly open, too, can be seen as inappropriate and indiscreet. Undue conscientiousness might be construed as prissiness, while excessive agreeableness might convey weakness.

How about neuroticism or its contrasting trait, stability? Someone who is anxious, depressed, and vulnerable is unlikely to wear well with either students or colleagues. And although it seems difficult to fault an undue level of stability in one’s colleagues, I suspect we have all served on committees where a professor’s invulnerability, calm, and self-assurance may have raised some questions. Where’s the fire?  Does he actually care deeply about his field? Is her deep calm a sign of a lack of interest? Where’s the edge?

Extraversion and the Academic Life

Let’s explore in greater detail one of the most important of the big five traits, extraversion. Like other dimensions of the big five, extraversion is known to have a moderately high degree of heritability. One biological model of this dimension postulates that differences in extraversion reflect differences in the arousal level of certain neo-cortical areas in the brain; those high in extraversion have low levels of arousal, while introverts have high levels.  Given that effective performance on daily tasks requires on optimal level of arousal, extraverts are typically seeking to increase their levels of arousal, while introverts are trying to lower theirs.

Optimal Level of Arousal

In everyday interactions at the university, introverts may avoid highly stimulating settings not because they are antisocial but because they realize that their performance is often compromised in such environments. Extraverts, on the other hand, may seek out such settings precisely because they have learned that they perform better when engaged in the cut and thrust of animated, even heated, exchanges.

Reaching an optimal level of arousal can also be achieved by the ingestion of beverages that have a direct impact on neo-cortical arousal.  Alcohol, at least initially, has the effect of lowering arousal. At the faculty club bar after a couple of glasses of wine, the extraverts are more likely to dip below the optimal arousal level while their introverted friends, nudged closer to optimal arousal, may appear unexpectedly garrulous.  Coffee, being a stimulant, has the opposite effect. After ingesting about two cups of coffee, extraverts carry out tasks more efficiently, while introverts perform less well. This deficit is magnified if the task they are engaged in is quantitative, and if it is done under time pressure. For an introverted professor, an innocent couple of cups of coffee before a meeting may prove challenging, particularly if the purpose of the meeting is a rapid-fire discussion of budget projections or similar quantitative concerns. In the same meeting, an extraverted colleague is likely to benefit from a caffeine kick that creates, in the eyes of the introverts, an illusion of competency.

Performance and Achievement: Twin Piques

Differences in extraversion also play a role in intellectual achievement. Generally speaking, and except for  one grade, introverts achieve higher marks in school so that by the time they are in university they are more likely to obtain a first- class graduating average. Why is this? Could it be that extraverts are simply less intelligent? The research suggests this is not so; there are no reliable differences in I.Q. between those scoring high and low on extraversion. I believe that it is the learning environment that is critical. Extraverts learn more in environments that are stimulating and engaging, and conventional schools may not be able to provide such an environment.

Consistent with the notion that engagement is central for extraverts, the introvert advantage in marks disappears when we look only at laboratory classes. And the one grade exception, where extraverts come home with a better report card? Kindergarten. Though tempting, it is probably not wise to predict later academic achievement on the basis of how our children did in kindergarten. Our extraverted children may well have peaked then!

There are two other areas of intellectual achievement where there are notable differences between those who are high and low on extraversion. Extraverts have better memories than introverts but only in short term memory. Introverts do better on long- term memory tasks. Also, when we engage in tasks, we can adopt two different strategies involving a quality/quantity tradeoff. We can do things quickly and make a few mistakes, or do things slowly and get it perfect. Extraverts are more likely to opt for quantity, introverts for quality.  These intellectual and cognitive differences can give rise to conflicts or at least mutual eyeball rolling between colleagues, especially when they are working on joint projects. Introverts, preferring a slow and careful approach to their tasks, see their extraverted colleagues as too “crash, bang, wallop” and want to rein them in. Extraverts can become exasperated at the style of their introverted colleague. They want them to speed up and get things done, even if there are a few little mistakes.  As any department chair can attest, when such creatures are housed together, periods of protracted pique can ensue.

Social Interaction: Communication Styles

If we watch social interactions in our university departments, we can easily spot the difference between introverted and extraverted styles. Their non-verbal interaction styles differ sharply. Extraverts stand closer but speak more loudly; they tend to touch and poke.  Introverts are less intense, more subdued, and definitely less pokey. As a result of these differences, when extraverts and introverts interact, it can look like a rather bizarre dance:-a series of alternating lunges, retreats, pokes, and aversions. This is not suave.

They also have contrasting verbal styles. Extraverts use direct, simple, concrete language. Introverts have a tendency to craft more oblique, contingently complex, weasel-word communications (more or less, at times, or so it appears).  Like that. Such differences can create all manner of friction within our departments with, once again, much rolling of eyes and gritting of teeth.

Although I hope to have shown that examining our relatively fixed traits of personality helps to explain some aspects of daily academic life, I suggested at the outset that I only partially agreed with the trait theorists. To explain my reservations I need to introduce a very different way of explaining human personality.  If we want to understand human personalities, I think we need to know not only the traits that people have but also the deeds that they do.  In those doings of daily life we begin to see some of the subtleties that are missed when we restrict ourselves to notions of fixed traits.

Personal Projects and Free Traits:On Acting Out of Character

One way of thinking about daily deeds is to explore the personal projects that guide them. Personal projects can range from the trivial pursuits of typical Tuesdays to the overarching commitments of a lifetime, and they provide a vital link between people and their institutions. Our academic lives are constructed around personal projects such as “get tenure,” “teach well,” or “terminate with a least a shred of dignity.”  Whether our projects go well or not depends, in part, upon relatively fixed traits of personality.  However, personal projects also give rise to what I call “free traits”, and these play a subtle, yet powerful, role in influencing the shape of lives.

Free traits are strategic displays that run counter to a person’s fixed traits but that advance that person’s personal projects. In two different senses such free- trait behavior can be said to be acting out of character. It is out of character in the sense that it involves acting against one’s first nature.  It is also an expression of one’s “character” and the values that enjoin us to rise to occasions. There are both costs and benefits to acting out of character. To the extent that the free trait is enacted successfully, the person’s project has been advanced. Short bursts of acting out of character need not be costly; these are the brief occasions we rise to, quickly, and then beat a hasty retreat to the faculty club to recover from, slowly. But protractedly acting out of character can extract a cost, including increased activity of the fight-flight reaction in the sympathetic nervous system and potential burnout.

Consider, for example, a biological introvert who has a core personal project of exciting students about the course material. Such a  professor may engage in “pseudo-extraverted” behaviour in order to help advance the teaching project.  It is possible that that the project might fail; there may be too much of a discrepancy between the professor’s natural orientation and the free trait that is being expressed.  But if the free-trait enactment is successful, the students are excited, and the project is accomplished. But even if successful in class, acting out of character can extract a toll. Fortunately, there are ways of mitigating these costs, but they require a change in the way that we relate to our colleagues.

Restorative Niches: A Free Trait Agreement for Academia

The costs of acting out of character can be mitigated by the availability of restorative niches in which one’s first nature can be indulged on occasion.  For example, I happen to be an introvert who frequently engages in extraverted free-trait behaviour in the classroom. If I can give some engaging anecdotes or involve the students in playful banter, then I do it happily but not really naturally. A far more congenial style for me is teaching one-on-one, which is a classic introvert preference. If you were to observe me in lecture, however, I suspect you would not detect any signs of introversion. However, there is one clear clue that emerges during the break we have half way through the lecture. A true extravert would find the break a great time to chat with the students and get energized for the second half of the lecture. But I need to get away from the stimulation that has been building during the extraverted performance. So at the break I seek out a restorative niche. If the lecture hall is near my office, I can find peace behind a closed door. But when the lecture is some distance from my office, I need to be more creative. Many years ago I discovered that the men’s room afforded me just the respite I needed. I would find a quiet cubicle, lower my level of arousal, and nurture my first nature. However, extraverts have a way of tracking professors down, and after a few instances of intrusive, inter-cubicle chats, I had to refine my escape tactics. So now, at the break, you will find me in the men’s room, in the last cubicle, restoring myself. But to avoid detection, my feet are up.

Free-trait enactment is not restricted to introverts who give extraverted performance. Extraverts in academe often need to switch into introvert mode, and their restorative niche would not be solitude but, rather, the most stimulating place on campus. Highly agreeable professors may, at times, need to be disagreeable; it comes with the turf in senior administrative positions, for example. But if being disagreeable moves from being an occasional tactic to a chronic commitment, then a naturally agreeable person will need frequent restoration to make it through without burning out. A restorative niche in this case would be a context in which cynicism is left at the door, and bitterness banned for the duration.

Each of these instances of professors acting out of character could be addressed if we were to agree to a Free Trait Agreement. Of course this wouldn’t be a formal agreement; it would be a set of shared understanding about how to respect our colleagues’ needs for restoration after they have been acting out of character in the services of the immortal profession. It would basically say that we will act out of character to advance the needs of our students and our universities, provided they, in turn, grant us, as needed, restorative niches in which we can nurture our natures. Such an agreement is already in place in departments and institutions that place a premium on collegial respect. With that respect and with those restorative resources, we can more than muddle through the challenges of academic life. Without them, the pressures of professing can be truly punitive and they can bring us to our knees.

Cover of Academic Matters Magazine

Published in the April-May 2010 Issue of Academic Matters Magazine

Professor Brian R. Little is Distinguished Scholar in the Department of Social and Developmental Psychology at Cambridge University. This article began as a keynote presentation at the Congress of Humanities and Social Sciences at Carleton University in 2009.

 

 

 

752 thoughts on “Acting Out of Character in the Immortal Profession: Toward a Free Trait Agreement

  1. Pingback: nouveau maillot Marseille

  2. Pingback: cheap ray ban sunglasses

  3. Pingback: china

  4. Pingback: Cheap dre headphones

  5. Pingback: Nike Roshe Run Mens

  6. Pingback: Cheap Nike Air Max 2014

  7. Pingback: Cartier trinity ring

  8. Pingback: Nike Roshe Run Women

  9. Pingback: Moncler Outlet online

  10. Pingback: http://www.dibaq.com/ing/petcare.aspx??cheap-nike-air-max-uk

  11. Pingback: cheap Nike air max 90

  12. Pingback: Cartier Love Bracelet

  13. Pingback: Cartier Love Bracelet

  14. Pingback: Cheap Beats by dr dre Headphones Solo

  15. Pingback: Hermes H Bracelet

  16. Pingback: Coach Purse Outlet

  17. Pingback: Cartier Love Ring

  18. Pingback: moncler homme

  19. Pingback: lululemon yoga pants

  20. Pingback: sOPdDxeI

  21. Pingback: Cheap Nike Air Max 90

  22. Pingback: Cartier Love Ring

  23. Pingback: Coach Factory Outlet

  24. Pingback: Cartier Love Ring

  25. Pingback: Coach Outlet Online

  26. Pingback: Cartier love bracelet

  27. Pingback: Cartier Love Bracelet Replica

  28. Pingback: http://www.englandbasketball-shop.co.uk/order/RoshRun.aspx

  29. Pingback: Cartier Replica Watches Mens

  30. Pingback: Cartier Love Bracelet

  31. Pingback: Cartier Love Bracelet

  32. Pingback: Cartier Love Bracelet

  33. Pingback: gucci outlet

  34. Pingback: Cartier Love Bracelet

  35. Pingback: Cheap Nike free 5.0

  36. Pingback: ondasurnoticias.com/?id=191

  37. Pingback: http://www.core-bp.com/tokyojpclothes/Jacket/3LTL2wYErs.html

  38. Pingback: http://www.nfjc-ksa.com/tokyowatch/Omegawatches/zUUDwDOQ2H.html

  39. Pingback: Coach Wallets for Men

  40. Pingback: http://www.chsboosters.org/tokyowatches/HAMILTON/j7lDEa0704.html

  41. Pingback: http://corebusinesspsychology.com/tokyojewelry/BloodyMary/RYgxE4i9pB.html

  42. Pingback: basket louboutin pas cher

  43. Pingback: cmssuperheroes.com/?id=144

  44. Pingback: http://embroidery.smvinc.com/tokyobags/LOEWE/H0liYf6LM4.html

  45. Pingback: http://family.coreen.biz/tokyowatch/Rolex/O1fo0h2Q0u.html

  46. Pingback: http://www.englishgoldens.net/tokyojpclothes/Tops/Glc0D7s1nS.html

  47. Pingback: louboutin pas cher

  48. Pingback: Prada CERNIERA SU TRE LATI Portafoglio in Pelle M605 in nero

  49. Pingback: http://www.ustaogluotomotiv.com/tokyojewelry/Swarovski/1FJLDTXZHR.html

  50. Pingback: house of fraser karen millen dresses

  51. Pingback: http://www.austinreptileservice.net/Tires4/NITTO/G6L2LDPw4s.html

  52. Pingback: cheap jordan shoes for sale

  53. Pingback: http://www.jnk.johnfishersr.net/golf1/Callaway/GwC6aBrUMS.html

  54. Pingback: Moncler Outlet

  55. Pingback: http://whaleprojects.com/Tires1/NANKANG/Seq2ZGuiEI.html

  56. Pingback: http://goldenshores.ca/golf3/Bridgestone/CZBAchij8J.html

  57. Pingback: http://www.lilieonline.com/Tires7/FALKEN/MBmtfEVJQS.html

  58. Pingback: http://www.talkxtra.co.uk/ghanaUK/loads.php?id=294

  59. Pingback: replica dior handbags

  60. Pingback: Cheap dr dre headphones

  61. Pingback: beyonce timberland instagram

  62. Pingback: prada 1bo3m1

  63. Pingback: http://duracomm.com/read.asp?moncler-jackets

  64. Pingback: http://www.exhibitionsinternational.org/osakaTires/DUNLOP/3hsk1L7vIl.html

  65. Pingback: prada scarpe collezione primavera estate 2013

  66. Pingback: abercrombie fitch nyc store locator

  67. Pingback: mcm bags from china

  68. Pingback: mcm bag expensive

  69. Pingback: mcm bag di jakarta

  70. Pingback: mcm electronics store

  71. Pingback: mcm backpack visetos

  72. Pingback: abercrombie et fitch champs elysees horaires

  73. Pingback: sweat hollister gris homme

  74. Pingback: magasin hollister au canada

  75. Pingback: abercrombie et fitch doudoune

  76. Pingback: abercrombie et fitch espagne

  77. Pingback: gucci online tracking

  78. Pingback: hollister lyon en hollister lyon emploi

  79. Pingback: celine chaussures fourrure

  80. Pingback: replica hermes birkin bags china

  81. Pingback: montre hermes bijoux mauboussin

  82. Pingback: basket jordan paris vii

  83. Pingback: louboutin homme objet definition

  84. Pingback: magasin hollister dans le monde

  85. Pingback: cheap jordans

  86. Pingback: gucci mane north pole livemixtapes

  87. Pingback: mk bags imitation breitling watches navitimer

  88. Pingback: prada candy spot 2014

  89. Pingback: mcm marke wiki

  90. Pingback: air jordan pas cher

  91. Pingback: mens abercrombie & fitch

  92. Pingback: mulberry sale rugby 2015

  93. Pingback: ray ban soleil city horaires

  94. Pingback: mk bags news san diego

  95. Pingback: prada outlet

  96. Pingback: mulberry bags store return policies

  97. Pingback: timberland men's 7-eye gore-tex chukka boot

  98. Pingback: longchamp knokke openingsuren

  99. Pingback: ray ban wayfarer tutti i modelli

  100. Pingback: 2009 prada shoes for men

  101. Pingback: timberland pro insulated boots

  102. Pingback: mulberry sale dubai jobs employment

  103. Pingback: prada saffiano cameo 30 price

  104. Pingback: Gregory Smith

  105. Pingback: toms 9.0 messenger

  106. Pingback: prix ray ban vision future a nice

  107. Pingback: toms zig zag kid

  108. Pingback: prada dresses on ebay

  109. Pingback: longchamp cosmos shoulder flap hobo

  110. Pingback: foulard hermes rare

  111. Pingback: basket jordan xi hu

  112. Pingback: montre hermes orange adsl

  113. Pingback: basket jordan junior seau

  114. Pingback: louboutin femme islam channel

  115. Pingback: gucci museum

  116. Pingback: hollister lyon numero

  117. Pingback: kate moss designs for longchamp

  118. Pingback: hermes occasion electromenager allemagne

  119. Pingback: jordan femme lion et homme cancer

  120. Pingback: faux sac celine phantom

  121. Pingback: picture fram

  122. Pingback: louboutin homme geant discount

  123. Pingback: mulberry sale handbags and hearts

  124. Pingback: ray ban round sunglasses dupe

  125. Pingback: sac longchamp s dimensions

  126. Pingback: louboutin femme kangourou en peluche

  127. Pingback: sac longchamp rouge au galop pas chere

  128. Pingback: michael kors eyeglasses price

  129. Pingback: timberland handtaschen online-shop

  130. Pingback: montre hermes ebay spain

  131. Pingback: nike shox white and orange

  132. Pingback: mcm outlet taschen

  133. Pingback: gucci borse uomo

  134. Pingback: toms xap installer javascript

  135. Pingback: pink toddler timberland boots uk

  136. Pingback: hogan donna primavera 2014

  137. Pingback: louboutin homme kaka new actualite

  138. Pingback: red timberland boots dtlr

  139. Pingback: hobo bag gucci

  140. Pingback: christian louboutin louis men's flats black

  141. Pingback: air jordan 6 infrared release date uk

  142. Pingback: high quality fake ray ban wayfarer

  143. Pingback: ray ban rx5287 eyeglasses color 2034

  144. Pingback: sciarpa gucci

  145. Pingback: mulberry purse repairs to alloy wheels

  146. Pingback: louboutin femme messi jpg

  147. Pingback: montevarchi prada outlet

  148. Pingback: кредит на карту онлайн

  149. Pingback: louboutin daffodile in heels

  150. Pingback: michael kors coupons 2011

  151. Pingback: toms discount motorcycle tires

  152. Pingback: взять онлайн займ

  153. Pingback: site d escarpins pas cher

  154. Pingback: michael kors handbag jet set travel leather medium shoulder bag

  155. Pingback: chaussures louboutin homme pas cher

  156. Pingback: tiffany つくば

  157. Pingback: dior belt

  158. Pingback: oakley 求人

  159. Pingback: フルラ 財布 三つ折

  160. Pingback: dior ノベルティ 2014

  161. Pingback: サングラス オークリー メンズ

  162. Pingback: vivienne westwood リバティン

  163. Pingback: コーチ アウトレット 店

  164. Pingback: オークリー サングラス 中古

  165. Pingback: negozio online hogan

  166. Pingback: christian louboutin vente

  167. Pingback: ugg 銉ゃ儠銈偗

  168. Pingback: フルラ ドレス

  169. Pingback: ケイトスペード 財布 オークション

  170. Pingback: フェンディ 時計 ループ

  171. Pingback: air jordan 11 gamma blue size 7.5

  172. Pingback: tiffany ペアネックレス

  173. Pingback: ケイトスペード 財布 ティアン 通販

  174. Pingback: casquette gucci pas cher

  175. Pingback: ブルガリ ブループールオム

  176. Pingback: ボッテガ 財布 ピンク

  177. Pingback: ブルガリ ペアリング 値段

  178. Pingback: ボッテガ 財布 人気色

  179. Pingback: jordan high tops black Friday 2014

  180. Pingback: シャネル chanel 財布

  181. Pingback: eau de parfum gucci

  182. Pingback: jordan alpha trunner black Friday sale

  183. Pingback: ポールスミス モテる

  184. Pingback: ボッテガヴェネタ メンズ 小物

  185. Pingback: チャンルー 糸 種類

  186. Pingback: ブルガリ ワイングラス

  187. Pingback: buyma furla

  188. Pingback: 横浜高島屋 bvlgari

  189. Pingback: boxing day prada fairy bag

  190. Pingback: furla キー

  191. Pingback: セリーヌ ミニラゲージ

  192. Pingback: cartier rotonde

  193. Pingback: 三田アウトレット

  194. Pingback: jordan shoe release black Friday 2014

  195. Pingback: カルティエ カリブル ダイバー

  196. Pingback: michael jordan shoes cyber Monday sale

  197. Pingback: canada goose カナダ グース kamloops カムループス tan

  198. Pingback: カナダグース ジャスパー フリークスストア

  199. Pingback: メンズ バッグ ブランド

  200. Pingback: モンクレール サカイ

  201. Pingback: gucci de gucci

  202. Pingback: コーチ アクセサリー

  203. Pingback: 御殿場 モンクレール

  204. Pingback: Black Friday michael kors handbags uk

  205. Pingback: モンクレール double

  206. Pingback: ニナリッチ バッグ

  207. Pingback: gucci enfants

  208. Pingback: gucci homme

  209. Pingback: boxing day abercrombie hoodies

  210. Pingback: コーチ バッグ 青

  211. Pingback: boxing day christian louboutin loafers

  212. Pingback: moncler モンクレール gauthier

  213. Pingback: モンクレール ヘルノ

  214. Pingback: mulberry small bayswater black friday 2014

  215. Pingback: mens louboutin sneakers black friday deals

  216. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch fierce cyber monday deals

  217. Pingback: カナダグース シャトー サイズ

  218. Pingback: mulberry bags cyber monday deals

  219. Pingback: ニューバランス uk

  220. Pingback: 伊勢丹 モンクレール

  221. Pingback: ニューバランス fs996

  222. Pingback: モンクレー モンクレール

  223. Pingback: moncler rod

  224. Pingback: cyber Monday christian louboutin usa

  225. Pingback: モンクレール アウトレット サイト

  226. Pingback: nb 専門店

  227. Pingback: モンクレール どこの国 安い

  228. Pingback: ugg ブーツ タグ 色

  229. Pingback: モンクレール ダウン レディース モカシン

  230. Pingback: cyber Monday discount christian louboutin shoes

  231. Pingback: ニューバランス 420

  232. Pingback: cyber monday mulberry outlet uk

  233. Pingback: ugg ペコス

  234. Pingback: ニューバランス激安通販

  235. Pingback: christian louboutin store cyber Monday 2014

  236. Pingback: ugg モカシン 買った

  237. Pingback: boxing day mulberry luggage

  238. Pingback: カナダグース レディース 古着

  239. Pingback: nb スニーカー コラボ

  240. Pingback: アグオーストラリア 店舗

  241. Pingback: ニューバランス スニーカー レディース 通販

  242. Pingback: cyber monday abercrombie sweatpants

  243. Pingback: カナダグース ジャスパー 高島屋

  244. Pingback: cyber Monday christian louboutin wedges

  245. Pingback: ugg サイズ メンズ

  246. Pingback: ugg ブーツ アウトレット 楽天

  247. Pingback: カナダグース エクスペディションパーカ

  248. Pingback: ugg ブーツ 内側

  249. Pingback: cyber Monday louboutin men shoes

  250. Pingback: boxing day mulberry shepton mallet

  251. Pingback: ugg レディース ムートンブーツ

  252. Pingback: ugg 是什么

  253. Pingback: black friday mulberry outlet uk

  254. Pingback: コーチ アウトレット 店舗 アメリカ

  255. Pingback: アグオーストラリア

  256. Pingback: カナダグース サイズ ジャスパー

  257. Pingback: カナダグース アメリカ 価格

  258. Pingback: カナダグース レディース アローズ

  259. Pingback: black friday christian louboutin high heels

  260. Pingback: veste gucci

  261. Pingback: ゴールデングース

  262. Pingback: ニューバランス スニーカー おしゃれ メンズ

  263. Pingback: ugg ジュニア

  264. Pingback: sac bambou gucci

  265. Pingback: ugg ブーツ オーストラリア メンズ

  266. Pingback: mulberry purse cyber monday 2014

  267. Pingback: boxing day michael kors jewelry

  268. Pingback: christian louboutin sneakers for women cyber Monday sale

  269. Pingback: ugg ブーツ 手入れの仕方

  270. Pingback: 財布 レディース 人気

  271. Pingback: ugg ベリーボタン

  272. Pingback: hollister new york black friday sale

  273. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch jeans black friday deals

  274. Pingback: ugg ラバーソール

  275. Pingback: uggブーツ販売店

  276. Pingback: バリー 財布

  277. Pingback: あぐ ムートン

  278. Pingback: アグ クラシックトール

  279. Pingback: モンクレール ダウン メンズ サイズ1

  280. Pingback: abercrombie size chart black friday 2014

  281. Pingback: アグ クラシックミニ 偽物

  282. Pingback: louis vuitton 中古

  283. Pingback: プラダ ドライビングシューズ

  284. Pingback: モンクレール ダウン メンズ コーデ

  285. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch fierce black friday 2014

  286. Pingback: アグオーストラリア新作

  287. Pingback: louis vuitton ダミエ 財布

  288. Pingback: louis vuitton新作財布

  289. Pingback: prada メンズ 財布

  290. Pingback: プラダ ナイロン トート

  291. Pingback: mulberry outlet uk black friday 2014

  292. Pingback: 紳士用財布

  293. Pingback: アグブーツ取扱店

  294. Pingback: プラダ インフュージョン オム

  295. Pingback: お財布バッグ

  296. Pingback: Black Friday michael kors clearance

  297. Pingback: ヴィトン バッグ 修理

  298. Pingback: 財布 ヴィトン 激安

  299. Pingback: ルイヴィトンの長財布

  300. Pingback: vuitton 財布 新作

  301. Pingback: アグクラシックショートミニ

  302. Pingback: sac de luxe celine

  303. Pingback: louis vuitton 財布 新作

  304. Pingback: prada バッグ 買った

  305. Pingback: プラダ 名刺入れ

  306. Pingback: baskets gucci

  307. Pingback: vuitton 長財布

  308. Pingback: prada バッグ コットン

  309. Pingback: プラダ エドワード

  310. Pingback: ceinture hermes femme prix

  311. Pingback: アグ通販激安

  312. Pingback: louis vuitton 修理

  313. Pingback: lancel promo

  314. Pingback: プラダ バッグ 本物

  315. Pingback: アグアウトレット店

  316. Pingback: 財布 メンズ 人気ランキング

  317. Pingback: ルイヴィトン長財布 モノグラム

  318. Pingback: アグ 本物 見分け方

  319. Pingback: sac celine occasion

  320. Pingback: prada 財布 売る

  321. Pingback: ルイヴィトンバッグ カタログ

  322. Pingback: uggブーツとは

  323. Pingback: boxing day michael kors bags sale

  324. Pingback: プラダ 偽物 財布

  325. Pingback: 人気のバック

  326. Pingback: ceinture hermes pas chere

  327. Pingback: プラダ バッグ モバオク

  328. Pingback: louis vuitton新作財布

  329. Pingback: 財布 prada

  330. Pingback: louis vuitton マルチカラー

  331. Pingback: louis vuitton ストラップ

  332. Pingback: プラダ 通販

  333. Pingback: ヴィトン 財布 ヴェルニ

  334. Pingback: アグムートンスリッポン

  335. Pingback: プラダ 蛇革 財布

  336. Pingback: louis vuitton ショルダー

  337. Pingback: プラダ 新作

  338. Pingback: 人気長財布

  339. Pingback: プラダ チェーンウォレット

  340. Pingback: アグ 正規店

  341. Pingback: louis vuitton アウトレット

  342. Pingback: プラダ オンラインストア

  343. Pingback: hermes bracelet

  344. Pingback: ビィトン公式

  345. Pingback: アグ ブーツ オーストラリア

  346. Pingback: ルイヴィトンバッグ カタログ

  347. Pingback: alviero martini scarpe prezzi

  348. Pingback: gucci sac soldes

  349. Pingback: 長財布 ルイヴィトン

  350. Pingback: o プラダ バッグ は

  351. Pingback: louis vuitton公式サイト

  352. Pingback: プラダ バッグ 知恵袋

  353. Pingback: vetiver hermes

  354. Pingback: アグ ブーツ

  355. Pingback: petit sac gucci

  356. Pingback: bandoliera alviero martini uomo

  357. Pingback: ルイビトン店舗

  358. Pingback: プラダ 財布 返品

  359. Pingback: lancel pas cher

  360. Pingback: アグブーツ正規店

  361. Pingback: ルイヴィトン カードケース

  362. Pingback: prada サンダル

  363. Pingback: louis vuitton リュック

  364. Pingback: prada 手帳

  365. Pingback: ルイヴィトン 公式 財布

  366. Pingback: sacs birkin hermes pas cher

  367. Pingback: louis vuitton ピアス

  368. Pingback: プラダ バッグ イタリア

  369. Pingback: アグブーツ アウトレット

  370. Pingback: boxing day michael kors blue handbag

  371. Pingback: プラダ キャンディ

  372. Pingback: ヴィトン リング

  373. Pingback: プラダ ヘッドフォン

  374. Pingback: アグ最安値

  375. Pingback: モンクレール 登録

  376. Pingback: プラダ バッグ 品番

  377. Pingback: プラダ 財布 コピー

  378. Pingback: アグ ムートンブーツ クラシックミニ

  379. Pingback: モンクレール ワンピ

  380. Pingback: prada 財布 白

  381. Pingback: portefeuille celine

  382. Pingback: 財布 レディース プラダ

  383. Pingback: モンクレール 洋服

  384. Pingback: クロムハーツ 返品

  385. Pingback: トートバッグ プラダ

  386. Pingback: モンクレール 子供

  387. Pingback: 長財布 がま口 プラダ

  388. Pingback: クロムハーツ ブリーフケース

  389. Pingback: free followers on instagram

  390. Pingback: モンクレール 安く買うには

  391. Pingback: prada 財布 新作 2013 公式

  392. Pingback: クロムハーツ ムック本

  393. Pingback: モンクレール ユーザー登録

  394. Pingback: プラダ 六本木

  395. Pingback: sac celine belgique

  396. Pingback: モンクレール ユナイテッドアローズ

  397. Pingback: モンクレール ファー

  398. Pingback: portefeuille gucci homme

  399. Pingback: bobe gucci

  400. Pingback: モンクレール ドミニク

  401. Pingback: promo sac lancel

  402. Pingback: ou acheter sac celine

  403. Pingback: モンクレール 表参道

  404. Pingback: プラダ 公式通販

  405. Pingback: モンクレール ファー

  406. Pingback: air max jordan

  407. Pingback: クロムハーツ クラッチ

  408. Pingback: モンクレール 染め直し

  409. Pingback: montre gucci homme pas cher

  410. Pingback: ceinture hermes femme prix

  411. Pingback: モンクレール 良さ

  412. Pingback: プラダ ワンピース レンタル

  413. Pingback: casquette gucci

  414. Pingback: Black Friday shoes michael kors

  415. Pingback: クロムハーツ ダブルクロス

  416. Pingback: プラダ 中古

  417. Pingback: dernier sac celine

  418. Pingback: prada 財布 免税店 値段

  419. Pingback: air jordan retro 1 high

  420. Pingback: ugg レインブーツ

  421. Pingback: vetement celine

  422. Pingback: プラダ ブログ

  423. Pingback: クロムハーツ

  424. Pingback: how to get free instagram followers fast without following back

  425. Pingback: キーケース プラダ

  426. Pingback: ugg ポーチ

  427. Pingback: クロムハーツ タイニースタースタッド

  428. Pingback: nike air jordan 8

  429. Pingback: プラダ バッグ コピー

  430. Pingback: ugg モカシン 名古屋

  431. Pingback: クロムハーツ さいふ

  432. Pingback: ugg モカシン 正規品

  433. Pingback: プラダ 元町

  434. Pingback: lancel sac bandoulière

  435. Pingback: プラダ カードケース

  436. Pingback: プラダ ウォレット

  437. Pingback: sac celine vente en ligne

  438. Pingback: prada 携帯 価格

  439. Pingback: soldes christian louboutin

  440. Pingback: ugg ブーツ 即納

  441. Pingback: プラダ ヘアアクセサリー

  442. Pingback: chrome hearts パーカー

  443. Pingback: プラダナイロントートバッグ

  444. Pingback: クロムハーツ 結婚指輪 プラチナ

  445. Pingback: クロムハーツ 弟子

  446. Pingback: プラダ 日本橋高島屋

  447. Pingback: ugg ブーツ 見分け方

  448. Pingback: celine luggage mini

  449. Pingback: クロムハーツ 財布 価格

  450. Pingback: prada コート メンズ

  451. Pingback: ugg フラッフィー

  452. Pingback: クロムハーツ リング ランキング

  453. Pingback: プラダ ジャージ

  454. Pingback: sac phantom celine prix

  455. Pingback: ugg ブーツ 雪の日

  456. Pingback: キーケース プラダ

  457. Pingback: ugg ルーム

  458. Pingback: ventes privees lancel

  459. Pingback: プラダ キャンディ

  460. Pingback: michael jordan images

  461. Pingback: プラダ 無地tシャツ

  462. Pingback: prada 時計 メンズ

  463. Pingback: プラダ ワンピース

  464. Pingback: chrome hearts ピアス

  465. Pingback: jordan clothes

  466. Pingback: air jordan bred colorway

  467. Pingback: クロムハーツ ネックレス 値段

  468. Pingback: プラダ ドレス

  469. Pingback: space outlet prada incisa

  470. Pingback: prada メンズ コート

  471. Pingback: ugg ブーツ 着画

  472. Pingback: クロムハーツ チョコ

  473. Pingback: プラダ 路面店

  474. Pingback: trio alviero martini prezzo

  475. Pingback: hermes zucco

  476. Pingback: chrome hearts リング

  477. Pingback: プラダ 折りたたみ財布

  478. Pingback: portachiave alviero martini

  479. Pingback: https://bft.usu.edu/232vd

  480. Pingback: borsa hermes birkin outlet

  481. Pingback: プラダ 迷彩

  482. Pingback: scarpe prada luna rossa

  483. Pingback: sac bebe lancel

  484. Pingback: chrome hearts ブログ

  485. Pingback: pradaトートバッグアウトレット

  486. Pingback: キーケース プラダ

  487. Pingback: ugg モカシン レディース

  488. Pingback: プラダ レディース

  489. Pingback: ugg リボン ムートン

  490. Pingback: ugg ムートン

  491. Pingback: プラダ日本未入荷

  492. Pingback: prada キャンバス バッグ

  493. Pingback: クロムハーツ ワンピース

  494. Pingback: hermes birkin replica pret

  495. Pingback: timberland handcrafted boots

  496. Pingback: クロムハーツ 革

  497. Pingback: ugg モカシン 白

  498. Pingback: プラダ ランキング

  499. Pingback: クロムハーツ neチェーン

  500. Pingback: jual sepatu air jordan 4

  501. Pingback: プラダ バッグ 最新

  502. Pingback: gucci outlet in england

  503. Pingback: クロムハーツ ロンワンズ

  504. Pingback: prada 中古

  505. Pingback: lancel maroquinerie femme

  506. Pingback: scarpe timberland jakarta

  507. Pingback: gucci eyeglass

  508. Pingback: ugg モカシン 汚れませんか

  509. Pingback: プラダ ターコイズ

  510. Pingback: ugg モカシン アンスレーチャーム

  511. Pingback: クロムハーツ コロッケ

  512. Pingback: プラダ 北海道

  513. Pingback: ugg ミュール

  514. Pingback: クロムハーツ ブランド

  515. Pingback: プラダ タオル

  516. Pingback: hermes 24 faubourg

  517. Pingback: メンズ 財布 プラダ

  518. Pingback: pradaトートバッグ中古

  519. Pingback: ugg ヘッドホン

  520. Pingback: プラダ 創業者

  521. Pingback: クロムハーツ pop

  522. Pingback: scarpe jordan 2013 prezzo

  523. Pingback: timberland real estate investment trust

  524. Pingback: ugg モカシン 価格

  525. Pingback: プラダ アウトレット バッグ

  526. Pingback: ugg メンズ ムートン

  527. Pingback: クロムハーツ タイプ

  528. Pingback: hermes himalayan birkin bag price

  529. Pingback: borse timberland Pelle

  530. Pingback: クロムハーツ東京店

  531. Pingback: クロムハーツネックレス定価

  532. Pingback: timberland e shop france

  533. Pingback: プラダ 化粧品

  534. Pingback: ugg モカシン 名古屋

  535. Pingback: クロムハーツ buyma

  536. Pingback: ugg ルネッタ

  537. Pingback: timberland bianche

  538. Pingback: クロムハーツ ビーニー

  539. Pingback: クロムハーツ スペーサーリング

  540. Pingback: alviero martini prima classe handbags

  541. Pingback: alviero martini borse uomo

  542. Pingback: prada ナイロントート

  543. Pingback: ugg ムートンブーツ 格安

  544. Pingback: クロムハーツ バレッタ

  545. Pingback: クロムハーツ バングル

  546. Pingback: クロムハーツ 中古正規品

  547. Pingback: gucci pas cher ceinture

  548. Pingback: timberland clothing malaysia

  549. Pingback: chapter 7 bankruptcy

  550. Pingback: bankruptcy chapter 13

  551. Pingback: timberland negozio ufficiale

  552. Pingback: ceinture gucci vrai

  553. Pingback: filing bankruptcy

  554. Pingback: timberland outlet boots uk

  555. Pingback: all red timberland boots size 6

  556. Pingback: cartable longchamp cuir homme

  557. Pingback: sac gucci occasion homme

  558. Pingback: timberland 71512 boat shoes

  559. Pingback: prada diaper bags sale

  560. Pingback: bankruptcy chapter 11

  561. Pingback: bankruptcy forms

  562. Pingback: bankruptcy lawyers

  563. Pingback: celine sac docteur

  564. Pingback: prada to nada bruno

  565. Pingback: longchamp au sultan price

  566. Pingback: prada e store korea

  567. Pingback: prada large tessuto backpack

  568. Pingback: timberland rapper que 25

  569. Pingback: bracelet montre hermes double tour

  570. Pingback: timberland pro pit boss black soft toe

  571. Pingback: prada outlet store paris

  572. Pingback: longchamp balzane besace

  573. Pingback: prada purses store

  574. Pingback: Darren

  575. Pingback: prada outlet dubai

  576. Pingback: Julian

  577. Pingback: celine bag real price

  578. Pingback: ron

  579. Pingback: Derek

  580. Pingback: childrens tan timberland boots

  581. Pingback: longchamp veau foulonne blanc

  582. Pingback: Gene

  583. Pingback: cap hermes port frejus

  584. Pingback: acheter sac longchamp gsell

  585. Pingback: ernesto

  586. Pingback: mcm leather belts

  587. Pingback: timberland boots mens on sale

  588. Pingback: longchamp 1948 prix sac

  589. Pingback: timberland pro in san antonio

  590. Pingback: mike

  591. Pingback: mcm backpack online

  592. Pingback: jack

  593. Pingback: chafrancesure louboutin reduction

  594. Pingback: christian louboutin boots suede over

  595. Pingback: mcm london price

  596. Pingback: expo palais longchamp marseille 2014

  597. Pingback: timberland helix steel toe

  598. Pingback: louboutin simple pump platform

  599. Pingback: jordan femme kaka asif

  600. Pingback: mcm bookbag

  601. Pingback: chafrancesure louboutin mariage prix

  602. Pingback: timberland dubai careers

  603. Pingback: Cyber Monday gucci shoes on sale

  604. Pingback: Cyber Monday cheap christian louboutin shoes

  605. Pingback: Black Friday michael kors purses cheap

  606. Pingback: Black Friday jordan shoes store

  607. Pingback: Wayne

  608. Pingback: grca tree sale 2014

  609. Pingback: shaun

  610. Pingback: baby gucci boxing day 2014

  611. Pingback: bill

  612. Pingback: christian louboutin fifi black friday deals

  613. Pingback: bernard

  614. Pingback: mk handbags Cyber Monday 2014

  615. Pingback: mathew

  616. Pingback: gucci sneakers for men Cyber Monday sale

  617. Pingback: michael kors rain boots black friday deals

  618. Pingback: Black Friday girls jordan shoes

  619. Pingback: michael kors very hollywood black friday sale

  620. Pingback: latest jordan releases Black Friday deals

  621. Pingback: jessie

  622. Pingback: michael kors straw tote handbag

  623. Pingback: Stanley

  624. Pingback: christian louboutin sneakers for women black friday sale

  625. Pingback: michael kors wallets price

  626. Pingback: growing mulberry tree from cutting

  627. Pingback: christian louboutin uk Cyber Monday 2014

  628. Pingback: mulberry bayswater inspired bag

  629. Pingback: jordan shoes for sale Black Friday 2014

  630. Pingback: michael kors messenger bag black friday deals

  631. Pingback: Cyber Monday white gucci belt

  632. Pingback: boxing day michael kors uk stockists

  633. Pingback: black friday shoes christian louboutin

  634. Pingback: the mulberry tree song

  635. Pingback: jordan cp3 shoes Cyber Monday deals

  636. Pingback: louboutin shoes men black friday 2014

  637. Pingback: michael kors cosmetic bag Cyber Monday 2014

  638. Pingback: alberto

  639. Pingback: boxing day christian louboutin sample sale

  640. Pingback: jordan shoes for boys Black Friday 2014

  641. Pingback: michael kors ostrich wedges

  642. Pingback: Shaun

  643. Pingback: Stuart

  644. Pingback: Black Friday retro jordan

  645. Pingback: edwin

  646. Pingback: pigalle louboutin Cyber Monday sale

  647. Pingback: jordan golf shoes Cyber Monday 2014

  648. Pingback: michael kors black bag chain

  649. Pingback: marion

  650. Pingback: Duane

  651. Pingback: Brian

  652. Pingback: Derek

  653. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch india cyber monday sale

  654. Pingback: julian

  655. Pingback: Ben

  656. Pingback: hollister website black friday deals

  657. Pingback: air jordan alpha 1 id

  658. Pingback: dean

  659. Pingback: jimmie

  660. Pingback: hollister hoodies black friday sale

  661. Pingback: mcm outlet frankfurt

  662. Pingback: gucci store france

  663. Pingback: hollister t shirts black friday 2014

  664. Pingback: nike air jordan outlet store

  665. Pingback: Derrick

  666. Pingback: cyber monday hollister abercrombie

  667. Pingback: Roy

  668. Pingback: abercrombie kids size chart cyber monday 2014

  669. Pingback: harga mcm backpack asli

  670. Pingback: Frank

  671. Pingback: jordan casual shoes Cyber Monday deals

  672. Pingback: gucci sneakers 8.5

  673. Pingback: alfred

  674. Pingback: mulberry purse black friday deals

  675. Pingback: mcm zebra

  676. Pingback: mcm canada christmas sale

  677. Pingback: mcm brown wallet

  678. Pingback: mulberry bag outlet cyber monday 2014

  679. Pingback: boxing day mulberry luggage

  680. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch hoodies black friday 2014

  681. Pingback: timberland earthkeepers 2.0 adventure deck oxford

  682. Pingback: mcm backpack official website

  683. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch india cyber monday 2014

  684. Pingback: timberland pro gravel pit mining boots

  685. Pingback: mcm 41 cif file

  686. Pingback: Jason

  687. Pingback: Homer

  688. Pingback: Cyber Monday deals on hollister

  689. Pingback: timberland tackhead 8 black boots

  690. Pingback: mcm bag outlet cyber monday sale

  691. Pingback: timberland toddler boots n pants song

  692. Pingback: black friday timberland shoes sale

  693. Pingback: cyber monday mcm shoulder bag

  694. Pingback: timberland shoes good for hiking

  695. Pingback: abercrombie locations cyber monday sale

  696. Pingback: mcm ugg boots price

  697. Pingback: gucci online boutique uk

  698. Pingback: mcm shoulder bag black friday deals

  699. Pingback: milton

  700. Pingback: legit site for jordan shoes

  701. Pingback: arthur

  702. Pingback: sergio

  703. Pingback: timberland brown mens shoes

  704. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch london black friday 2014

  705. Pingback: cyber monday abercrombie sweatpants

  706. Pingback: brandon

  707. Pingback: timberland pro titan soft toe

  708. Pingback: gucci case for note 3

  709. Pingback: hollister jeans black friday 2014

  710. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch india cyber monday 2014

  711. Pingback: hollister boxing day

  712. Pingback: timberland boots youth size 6.5

  713. Pingback: timberland shoes for work

  714. Pingback: clinton

  715. Pingback: boxing day abercrombie outlet

  716. Pingback: black friday mcm hobo

  717. Pingback: air jordan 7 miro price

  718. Pingback: black friday abercrombie and fitch store locator

  719. Pingback: Gary

  720. Pingback: nike air jordan Black Friday sale

  721. Pingback: giant mcm 990 bike

  722. Pingback: arnold

  723. Pingback: Cecil

  724. Pingback: Marcus

  725. Pingback: benjamin

  726. Pingback: trevor

  727. Pingback: Homer

  728. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch india cyber monday sale

  729. Pingback: Eduardo

  730. Pingback: air jordan retro 1 bred size 11

  731. Pingback: black friday abercrombie and fitch canada

  732. Pingback: harold

  733. Pingback: longchamp ligne cavalier

  734. Pingback: black friday hollister for kids

  735. Pingback: sac toile longchamp pas cher

  736. Pingback: hollister boxing day

  737. Pingback: mcm handbags cyber monday sale

  738. Pingback: matt

  739. Pingback: sac longchamp roseau box

  740. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch uk black friday sale

  741. Pingback: mcm bags dubai price

  742. Pingback: mathew

  743. Pingback: abercrombie and fitch store locator cyber monday sale

  744. Pingback: mcm handbags replica

  745. Pingback: air jordan backpacks cheap

  746. Pingback: hermes solde

  747. Pingback: mcm bags for women

  748. Pingback: air jordan cleats size 7

  749. Pingback: shop mcm online

  750. Pingback: womens air jordan 5 v retro

  751. Pingback: mcm ladies sneakers

  752. Pingback: air jordan shoes 407494

Comments are closed.